CrimethInc. critique compilation - call for submissions

12 posts / 0 new
Last post
anon (not verified)
CrimethInc. critique compilation - call for submissions

We're seeking critiques of the CrimethInc Ex-Workers Collective, by anarchists and fellow travelers, to compile, ideally into a book.

Whether friendly or hostile, analytical or relational, timely or outdated, in prínciple we're open to a wide range of takes, as long as it seems clear that the subject of criticism is the specific group - and/or its social milieu - rather than anti-authoritarianism in the abstract.

If you're interested in making suggestions or collaborating on production, feel free to comment here or get in touch by email: ekitaph@espiv.net.

Wayne Price (not verified)
submission of 2 papers critiquing Crimethinc by Wayne Price

Response to Crimethinc’s “Why We Don’t Make Demands”
Debate among Anarchists over Raising Demands
https://www.anarkismo.net/article/28353?search_text=Wayne

Are Anarchism and Democracy Opposed? 
A Response to Crimethinc
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/wayne-price-are-anarchism-and-de...

anon (not verified)
Wayne and thecollective both

Wayne and thecollective both seethe and ressent CrimethInc. HOW CUTE and TELLING!

anon (not verified)
speaking of telling…

SR Troll, tell us all about how John Zerzan’s and Crimethinc ‘s writings are the most cutting edge, genius, amazing stuff put to paper…in the last 60 years, and everyone else sucks. Oh wait nevermind, you do that multiple times a day every day on here.

anon (not verified)
OoOokay, SR Sock....

OoOokay, SR Sock....

John Zerzan’s and Crimethinc ‘s writings are the most cutting edge, genius, amazing stuff put to paper…in the last 60 years, and everyone else sucks.

Happy? You just have to ask nicely. No need for such seething ressentiment.

M.Gouldhawke (not verified)
telling what?

Does seething and ressentiment preclude one from having an accurate critique of a particular position another person has, and is it possible to have a critique without seething and ressentiment? Seems to me that a person could be completely bonkers, the most seething and ressentiment-filled person in all of human history, and yet, if they called a cat a cat, it would still be a cat and would not become a dog just because of this particular person's supposedly unseemly personal qualities. Maybe mental illness or personal quirks can even improve a person's critique of others, in some cases. Who's to say?

Wayne Price (not verified)
My Attitude toward Crimethinc

I don't know about "the collective" or whoever is proposing to make this possible book, but I don't think I "seethe and ressent" {or "resent"] Crimethinc. My two essays are responses to two specific topics presented by C. Otherwise I agree with quite a lot of their politics. In particular, I respect C. for being for revolution--unlike most of the commenters on this list.

Wayne Price (not verified)
*Altitude

*Altitude

Wayne Price (not verified)
Longitude?

Not by me.

Wayne Price (not verified)
Any other submissions?

Hi,
Have there been any other submissions so far? Just curious.

Oak (not verified)
Jason Rodgers has a lengthy

Jason Rodgers has a lengthy review of crimethinc I'll try to make sure you get, in Oak 3

OP (not verified)
We have not yet received this

We have not yet received this. If you (or anyone) has a digital copy, feel free to send it to ekitaph@espiv.net.

Add new comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
r
T
m
!
d
5
3
R
Enter the code without spaces.