ANews Podcast 488 – 10.30.26

From ANews Podcast

Welcome to the ANews podcast. This podcast covers anarchist activity, ideas, and conversations from the previous week.

What’s New This Week
written by chisel and read by chisel and pessimism

Topic of the Week: Denial, Repentance, Restoration
a conversation with Cam and Smhoo

Sound editing by rocinante
music samples:
The Get Up Kids – Action & Action
Blvck Ceiling – no sleep. just dreams.
The Clash – Police on My Back – Remastered

Comments

anonymous (not verified) Sun, 11/01/2026 - 11:55

to cam: anarchists may or may not have ever opened a concentration camp, but we haven't started any either. 

Bugs Bunny (not verified) Sun, 11/01/2026 - 14:36

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

The CNT operated forced labour camps and issued identity papers for workers to be checked. Both were criticised repeatedly by the base for being too lenient(!). This false belief that anarchos were and are sanctified forever explains so much of the kneejerk moralism.

anonymous (not verified) Sun, 11/01/2026 - 19:21

In reply to by doubt (not verified)

this is a widely documented subject though some details are controversial - you can find as many sources as you want. in short, cnt joined the republican govt, one of them became minister of justice (an experienced and influential anarchist militant who is sometimes credited with inventing the red and black flag), and on 12/26/36 he issued an order establishing prison camps for enemies of the republican govt. here’s from michael seidman’s book “workers against work”, excerpted on libcom.org:

The Spanish Revolution, like the Russian, also had its labor camps (campos de trabajo), initiated at the end of 1936 by Juan García Oliver, the CNT Minister of Justice. The CNT recruited guards for the "concentration camps," as they were also called, from within its own ranks. Certain militants feared that the CNT’s resignation from the government after May 1937 might delay this "very important project" of labor camps. ...

According to a CNT historian, "delinquents, reactionaries, subversives, and suspects were judged by popular tribunals composed of CNT militants and, if found guilty, jailed or condemned to forced labor. Fascists, soldiers who looted, drunkards, criminals, and even syndicalists who abused their power were put behind bars or in work camps where they were forced to build roads."

Bugs Bunny (not verified) Mon, 11/02/2026 - 23:31

In reply to by anonymous (not verified)

Some children idolise Spiddeymon, some Danish bricks, in your case it is the CNT-FAI. Esoteric but unfortunate. Augustin Souchy writes about one in the Peasants of Aragon; ”Why are there still concentration camps? Because the war against fascism is not yet over. The anarchists must protect themselves against the fascists.” Dogshit argument by the way.

Michael Seidman in Workers against Work, “Santillán noted that “in a regime of organized work it is very difficult to live outside of production”;Leval warned that a “parasite” could obtain “nothing” during the Revolution. Even though Pestaña advocated industrial decentralization, he too wanted “work identity cards” to control slackers. Juan Peiró—who, with Pestaña, was a leader of the trentistas—complained that Spain was a “semicolonial country” whose people might need a good dose of repression to make the revolution succeed.[166] Another militant asserted that a libertarian communist society would not use force on those who did not wish to labor but would instead treat them as mentally unbalanced and allow them to wander about as long as they did not disturb social peace. One visionary advocated, when money was abolished, that “vagrants” be required to have their identity cards stamped by a union official to ensure that they could not avoid work. The 1936 CNT Congress of Zaragoza, which reunited moderate trentistas and more extremist faístas, proposed popular assemblies to discipline those who “do not fulfill their duties either in the moral order or in their functions as producers.”

That your mans? lol

anonymous (not verified) Tue, 11/03/2026 - 19:54

In reply to by Bugs Bunny (not verified)

I don't see evidence here that the "CNT operated forced labour camps and issued identity papers for workers to be checked." They proposed social control measures against the unproductives, and that's something to be expected from Workerists if they took any power, but concentration camps? GTFO, fool.

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
i
9
L
q
*
i
F
j
Enter the code without spaces.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.