Add new comment

To determine who won or lost at Seattle, look at the fate of the WTO talks-and the trade deal that was supposed to come from them. The opening ceremonies were shut down at the beginning, and what became the Doha Round of trade talks failed in the end. The objective of the WTO was not just to meet, but to get a brutal trade deal out of those talks. They failed. The objective of the protesters was ultimately to prevent a new WTO treaty from ever going into effect, and it never did.

The enemy did not achieve their stated objective, and ours was simply to stop them so we win and they lose. All that took place in between: the mass arrests, the Doha "reshoot" summit from which the trade round got its name, the Cancun WTO meeting from which 20 African nations walked out after that S Korean farmer committed suicide atop the police barricades are simply how the battle was fought. The outcome of the overall, years-long battle was the death of the WTO trade round, no new WTO treaty, as per our objective.

I still remember where I was: with Seattle out of range for me, I was at two DC solidarity actions: first was an old-growth logging protest at (I think) Farragut Square, then came a GMO protest near HHS featuring a 30 foot long "ear of corn" with bamboo handles on both sides that we maneuvered through the streets like rowing an ancient galley on land.

As for the IMF and World Bank, their meeting on A16 was badly hampered, anyone that didn't spend the night of April 15-16 inside did not get in, and the Federal government was shut down on the whole western side of DC on April 17, 2000. That summer, the World Bank cancelled a proposed loan to China to "resettle" Chinese farmers on stolen land in Tibet. You can bet A16 played a role in that. Years later, Hugo Chavez used oil money made from all those US SUV drivers to pay off the debts of many Central and South American countries, freeing them from debt bondage to those institutions. By the Great Recession they were actively looking for new missions.

There was also the World Economic Forum (either Australia or New Zealand, I forget which) on Sep 11, 2000. An estimate 2/3ds of the delegates failed to gain entry to the summit due to powerful street blockades. Nobody disputed who won that round.

By 2016, both Hillery Clinton and Donald Trump had to at least claim to oppose the TPP or Trans-Pacific Partnership, though both were expected to go back on their word in some way if elected. Trump pulled the US out of the TPP, the remaining nations were not free to remove USTR-imposed drug patent/GMO/etc terms from the "rump" TPP. Trump is now pushing TPP style provisions in his nasty NAFTA 2.0 proposal, but Corporate AmeriKKKa did NOT get the TPP itself. This isn't over, we have to stop NAFTA 2.0, which is pushed by both Trump and Pelosi but opposed by much of what remains of organized labor in the AFL/CIO style.