cob construction

Listening to a recent andrewism entry on the futility of policing language brought me, in my normal contrarian way, to a counter argument. Let me be clear, there is no counter argument that most policing (of any kind) is almost if not entirely about performing and purity, attempting to position the policer as the more knowledgeable, more connected, better person. But changing our own language can encourage us to think differently, especially if we don't turn it into something to attack other people with.

As is normal, most people are doing this wrong, at least most of the time. 

There is a reason why people pay attention to words--and to changing them to address problems.

Language creates a context, sets a frame, for how we interact with the world before we know, and sometimes without us ever knowing, it's happening. One obvious example: calling people "black" and 
"white" creates an inherent polarity that rests on centuries of (christian and enlightenment) mythology about white being good and black being scary. I can't imagine anyone would think that calling white people "pink" and black people "brown" is going to change anything immediate, but I do think there's an argument such a change could set the stage for more meaningful and longer-lasting changes. 

So let's not get distracted by telling people here how much better we do, and focus on how you prepare yourself, your world, your friends, your family, for the changes you would like to see, be, do.

  1. Do you prepare good food for your friends who don't know how to cook or are too broke to get good food?
  2. Do you have difficult conversations about past, present, or future events that people are avoiding?
  3. Do you learn how to do things for yourself because you figure at some point you'll be providing services for your friends?
  4. What are contextual differences between collective vs individual learning?
  5. What is your vision that you're attempting to frame out (however implicitly or tacitly)?

Comments

Le Way Mon, 10/05/2026 - 00:30

After a 12 month stint in jail I came out in a quasi-mystical anarch, feeling free and reckless, with a total denial of any restraint or limitation, somehow closer to Neech's idea of individual salvation.

Vulkangroupie (not verified) Mon, 10/05/2026 - 02:45

“There is a reason why people pay attention to words”. There is a reason why people like scat, Dua Lipa, Spideyman and WWE, this don’t make it correct. The point about language making us think differently is fair though, I see a lot more touchy retards these days.

fuck you (not verified) Mon, 10/05/2026 - 07:58

In reply to by Vulkangroupie (not verified)

it's so cool when you see people using language like this in anarchist spaces. really makes people with intellectual disabilities feel right at home to see the words that are used to demean and dehumanize them in spaces like this. i bet this is going to really help folks find community within anarchism. thanks for being an example of how anarchists are in solidarity with disabled folks. /s

asshole. edgelord ass piece of shit.

anonymous (not verified) Mon, 10/05/2026 - 08:24

one downside with not policing language though is "anarchists" believing going out of their way to be offensive (in language) and acting all put out if called on it is the height of anarchy.

But as to how I try to do it ...
early on in my anarchist journey I read a lot about pre-literate cultures and one bit of that I liked was the idea that all persons in a group (society, culture, whatever word here) knew all the things of that group. Meaning, everyone of age could do any task. I think we are not in such a group / world of course, and yet this colors my view of how to live. So, I try to be competent at all tasks I might be called upon to do. And I try to encourage or facilitate those around me to have the same attitude and skills. This is my ideal, and since the world we inhabit is overly complicated, this usually doesn't pan out. Still, the goal of everything for everyone, and everyone can do everything motivates me in how I try to live.

MOO (not verified) Tue, 10/06/2026 - 09:40

"Let me be clear, there is no counter argument that most policing (of any kind) is almost if not entirely about performing and purity, attempting to position the policer as the more knowledgeable, more connected, better person."

Do you really not see how your position is essentially policing the police and that you yourself are performing purity to appear more knowledgeable than "most people" who "are doing this wrong, at least most of the time"?

Your entire topic is predicated on your enlightened correctness over others to try and get them to conform to youthink.

Consider having some (no)self-awareness and reduce smugness.

But since I love me some lists, I'll answer your questions:

1. When possible.
2. No future.
3. No future.
4. One and the same.
5. Destroy.

Have a nice now.

anonymous (not verified) Tue, 10/06/2026 - 12:31

The pivot of this prompt throws me a bit, it's kind of all over the place. I think being intentional in how I speak and trying to be precise, rather than speaking in broad epithets for example, helps me communicate. Certain terms might make sense to certain groups and not at all to others, but either way I'd rather not mince words...that may also come with aging. It will always be imperfect but I do my best to be sincere in any case.

That follows my physical actions too, which means sharing food with anyone that wants in when the opportunity presents itself. Skills and knowledge are important to me so I like learning and try to share whatever I learn with any friends that want in, even if I'm far from an expert. This sets the stage for more people, as the anon mentions above, are more broadly capable -- even though we'll still likely stick to our specialties. My vision is to be capable of tearing down and living without the state, capital, or other mediations -- but maybe that's too obvious on an anarchist site?

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
d
$
5
V
A
a
#
m
Enter the code without spaces.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.